On October 17, 1994, Anjanette called in sick to her job at 01:30. Later that morning a Blasdell mechanic reported seeing Anjanette in the passenger seat of her car, with her former fiance's father driving. He had stopped to check on his car that was in for repairs. The man indicates that after leaving the repair shop, they went to Broderick Park in Buffalo, NY, had an argument, and he left, walking home.